How to Have the Best Organic Soil in the Neighborhood

The best garden comes from the best soil; improve soil and you’ll improve your harvest. Here’s how to work on building soil for better crop yield and healthier plants in your vegetable garden. 

One of the best places to start? Stop using poisons to control weeds. Instead, try these natural weed killer ideas.

good garden soil with a trowel full of pea seeds

Building soil for a good harvest

Let’s be clear about this: If your soil is junk, your organic garden is going to struggle. Years ago we ordered a truckload of “garden soil” to fill brand new garden beds. What arrived was a pitiful pile of dirt and rocks. We struggled that first year, trying to get anything to grow. Within a few years, though, the garden was thriving thanks to a lot of work to improve the soil.

Fifteen years later, I’m again struggling with puny soil — but I know what to do to fix it!

Good garden soil is the key to successful growing, but whenever I ask someone about how to make the best organic soil or start doing any research, my eyes glaze over with all of the details. Some people love the details (N.P.K.! Ph! Acidity!) but not me. It’s too overwhelming. I know I need good organic soil, but I don’t want to spend tons of time getting there. I’m not a scientist; I just want to dig in the dirt. Good dirt.
white turnips growing in garden soil

In previous gardens, I’ve had good luck improving my garden soil without testing. I’m not anti-testing; I just don’t think it’s always as necessary as some soil experts would have you believe. If you’ve got a serious problem, soil testing can help you pinpoint it, but poor soil can often be fixed without a PhD.

In my new garden space, the soil is puny. It doesn’t hold moisture at all; the water just drains right on past the plant’s roots, and probably waves as it goes by. There don’t seem to be a lot of nutrients, because the things I’ve planted are just failing to thrive. They’re not dying, but they’re not doing well, either.

Related: How to Use Urine in the Garden

compost in a grey tub

Building soil in three easy steps

  • Add rotted manure
  • Add compost
  • Mulch

(I don’t use chemical fertilizers, but if you do, you need to add a fourth step: Stop using chemical fertilizers to improve soil! Synthetic fertilizers deplete the soil and harm the environment.)

Adding compost and rotted manure boosts the nutrient content of your garden soil and improves its ability to maintain a nice moisture balance in your organic garden. Using mulch helps to retain moisture, hold weeds at bay, and as it decomposes, it adds nutrients, making for the best soil you can grow a garden in.

Improve soil right on site

In a perfect world, you’d be able to build good organic soil with what you have on hand. A speaker at a recent workshop said he’d leave a portion of his land wild, just so he’d have plant materials to turn into mulch right on site. (Check out this post about how to grow plants for mulch.) That’s a great way to reduce inputs. Here are a few others:

  • Keep small livestock. Rabbit manure makes great fertilizer that can go directly on the garden. Chickens, goats, sheep, and cows (okay, so they’re big) make great poop, too, though you’ll need to let it sit for several months to mellow.
  • Turn your kitchen scraps and yard waste into compost.
  • Invest in a lawn mower bag so you can capture the green clippings. They’re great mulch for veggie gardens.
  • If you don’t have room for a large compost pile, not to worry. Even apartment dwellers can use the vermicomposting method to transform kitchen waste into a gorgeous soil amendment. Here’s how I made a worm composter for less than five bucks. It’s easy, and I promise — it doesn’t stink! The castings are great for improving organic soil.

You can use the compost, castings, and rotted manure as top or side dressings right alongside your vegetable plants in your organic garden. The mulch can be applied four to six inches deep all around the base of each plant.

small basil plant in rich soil

Where to find the best soil amendments

Unfortunately, it’s not a perfect world and often we need to import amendments. Finding a local source of manure is ideal: no plastic packaging and little energy wasted to get the poop from the source to your house. Chicken, goat, rabbit, cow, and horse manure are all fair game for your organic garden. (But note that what they’ve eaten or been treated with can impact that “organic” designation.)

A savvy nursery person I know suggests that even llama manure is good stuff, but I suspect that may be a little harder to come by. Dairies and boarding stables are your best bet for finding an endless supply of manure, but consider smaller scale operations, too. For example, a 4-Her who is raising rabbits but doesn’t have a garden might be willing to trade poop now for tomatoes from your organic garden later.

Most landscape material companies will sell you a truckload of bulk compost so you can eliminate the plastic bags.

seedlings in containers from above


Use caution when importing amendments

Here’s something to know about if you’re purchasing manure and compost, either in bulk or bags: Manufactured compost and products labeled as manure might contain biosolids. Made from sludge leftover from industrial waste water or sewage treatment plants, many biosolids are approved by the EPA for use on agricultural crops.

Now, I don’t know about you, but I’m not very comfortable with the thought of spreading biosolids from an entire town on my organic garden in my efforts to build soil. I have no way of knowing what each of those, um, contributors added to the collection. Medications, harsh cleaners, poisons? While the EPA insists that biosolids are completely safe (and nutrient rich!) as long as they pass certain safety tests, there are plenty of other studies that say otherwise.

Based on a 2010 study, Environmental Science and Technology reports that:

Many pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) are commonly found in biosolids and effluents from wastewater treatment plants. Land application of these biosolids and the reclamation of treated wastewater can transfer those PPCPs into the terrestrial and aquatic environments, giving rise to potential accumulation in plants.

In a 2008 study the USGS found that:

Earthworms studied in agricultural fields where manure and biosolids were applied have been found to contain organic chemicals from household products and manure. Earthworms continuously ingest soils and may accumulate any soil contaminants into their bodies. The chemicals detected included the active ingredients commonly found in a variety of household products—including the disinfectant found in antibacterial soaps, fragrances used in perfumes and detergents, and pharmaceuticals.

I think I’ll avoid biosolids, thanks.

If you’d like to avoid biosolids in your vegetable garden, here’s how make some of your own garden products at home. And here’s what to watch for if you’re buying packaged amendments:

  • Manure products that are labeled 100% steer manure or 100% chicken manure. If it’s not 100%, what else is in there?
  • Compost that lists the ingredients. If you see the word “biosolids” you can cross it off your list, but what about those “inert ingredients?” I’d be a little leery of a product that promises to be “enhanced,” too.
  • Find a trustworthy product and stick with it. I buy Fox Farms products when I can’t find manure or compost in bulk, and they assure me that they do not use biosolids in their products.
bright red stems on swiss chard

Hot tips to improve soil from gardeners in the know

  • Using a mix of peat, lime, coarse sand or perlite, fertilizer, compost and soil, the folks over at Grow a Good Life show us how to make soil blocks. Planting seeds into soil blocks eliminates the need to remove seedlings from pots as you plant them; the seedling and soil block can be popped right into your garden. No root stress!
  • But if you’re not using wood mulch, what can you use for building soil, you ask? Try using grass mulch to hold in soil moisture and help combat weeds.
  • Susan over at Learning and Yearning is a Master Gardener and knows what she’s talking about when she promises that compost is black gold. Her post addresses the basics of composting and includes a list of some of the things you can add to your compost bin. (Susan is also the author of The Art of Gardening: Building Your Soil.)

Want to learn more about building good organic soil?

Susan Vinskofski is a Master Gardener in Pennsylvania County and has been gardening for much of her life. She’s what you’d call savvy about gardening, and she’s passionate about doing it from the ground up. Er, the soil up. Her ebook, The Art of Gardening: Building Your Soil, is a thorough discourse on building soil that will help your garden thrive.

cover of book: the art of gardening

Improve soil for a great vegetable garden

The best soil = the best garden. Really. The soil matters. Susan shares specifics about soil improvement and methods for building soil in interesting, easy to follow detail.

You’ll learn about sheet mulching, compost, and why rototilling isn’t recommended. But the book doesn’t stop at how to improve soil. The author also covers seeds and how to successfully germinate them, choosing your garden site, and staking/trellising. The final chapter is an alphabetical guide to garden plants (complete with some recipes for cooking up your harvest).

I had the opportunity to read Susan’s book before she released it. It’s simply gorgeous; the artwork by Deb Hamby is a treat for the eyes (completely frame-worthy, in my opinion) and a great accompaniment to Susan’s informative, easy to read text.

This is a great resource for novice gardeners looking to build organic soil, and even those of us who have been at it for awhile — I learned a thing or two!

watercolor paintings of seed packets

Want to know more about Susan’s book and how to build good soil? Head on over to her site to see more about the contents and to download some sample pages.

Originally published in 2016; this post has been updated.

Click to save or share!

About the author: Kris Bordessa is an award-winning National Geographic author and a certified Master Food Preserver. Read more about Kris and how she got started with this site here. If you want to send Kris a quick message, you can get in touch here.

0 comments… add one

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *