Good soil is the key to successful growing, but whenever I read or ask someone about how to make good soil, though, my eyes glaze over with all of the details. Some people love the details (N.P.K.! Ph! Acidity!) but not me. It’s too overwhelming. I know I need good soil, but I don’t want to spend tons of time getting there. I’m not a scientist; I just want to dig in the dirt. Good dirt.
In previous gardens, I’ve had good luck improving the soil without testing. I’m not anti-testing; I just don’t think it’s always as necessary as some soil experts would have you believe. If you’ve got a serious problem, soil testing can help you pinpoint it, but poor soil can probably be fixed without a PhD.
In my new garden space, the soil is puny. It doesn’t hold moisture at all; the water just drains right on past the plant’s roots, and probably waves as it goes by. There don’t seem to be a lot of nutrients, because the things I’ve planted are just failing to thrive. They’re not dying, but they’re not doing well, either.
My soil improvement plan in two easy steps:
- Add rotted manure
- Add compost
(I don’t use chemical fertilizers, but if you do, you need to add a third step: stop using chemical fertilizers! Chemical fertilizers deplete the soil and harm the environment.)
Adding compost and rotted manure boosts the nutrient content of the soil and improves its ability to maintain a nice moisture balance.
Finding a local source of manure is ideal: no plastic packaging and little energy wasted to get the poop from the source to your house. Chicken, goat, rabbit, cow, and horse manure are all fair game for your garden. A savvy nursery person I know suggests that even llama manure is good stuff, but I suspect that may be a little harder to come by. Dairies and boarding stables are your best bet for finding an endless supply of manure, but consider smaller scale operations, too. For example, a 4-Her who is raising rabbits but doesn’t have a garden might be willing to trade poop now for tomatoes later.
Homemade compost or worm castings are another great low impact amendment for your garden, but if you’re just starting to compost, you won’t likely have much to add to your garden this year. Most landscape materials companies will sell you a truckload of compost that will eliminate the plastic bags.
Here’s something to know about if you’re purchasing manure and compost, either in bulk or bags: Manufactured compost and products labeled as manure might contain biosolids. Made from sludge leftover from industrial waste water or sewage treatment plants, many biosolids are approved by the EPA for use on agricultural crops. Now, I don’t know about you, but I’m not very comfortable with the thought of spreading biosolids from an entire town on my garden. I have no way of knowing what each of those, um, contributors added to the collection. Medications, harsh cleaners, poisons? While the EPA insists that biosolids are completely safe (and nutrient rich!) as long as they pass certain safety tests, there are plenty of other studies that say otherwise.
Based on a 2010 study, Environmental Science and Technology reports that:
Many pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) are commonly found in biosolids and effluents from wastewater treatment plants. Land application of these biosolids and the reclamation of treated wastewater can transfer those PPCPs into the terrestrial and aquatic environments, giving rise to potential accumulation in plants.
In a 2008 study the USGS found that:
Earthworms studied in agricultural fields where manure and biosolids were applied have been found to contain organic chemicals from household products and manure. Earthworms continuously ingest soils and may accumulate any soil contaminants into their bodies. The chemicals detected included the active ingredients commonly found in a variety of household products—including the disinfectant found in antibacterial soaps, fragrances used in perfumes and detergents, and pharmaceuticals.
I think I’ll avoid biosolids, thanks. If you’d like to avoid biosolids in your vegetable garden, here’s what to watch for if you’re buying packaged amendments:
- Manure products that are labeled 100% steer manure or 100% chicken manure. If it’s not 100%, what else is in there?
- Compost that lists the ingredients. If you see the word “biosolids” you can cross it off your list, but what about those “inert ingredients?” I’d be a little leery of a product that promises to be “enhanced,” too.
- Don’t trust the word “organic” in this case. Even products that include biosolids can be labeled as organic.
- Find a trustworthy product and stick with it. I buy Fox Farms products when I can’t find manure or compost in bulk, and they assure me that they do not use biosolids in their products.