Growing persimmons for a late fall harvest on your homestead. Here’s how to decide between an American persimmon tree or a Fuyu persimmon tree.
When I was growing up, my grandpa couldn’t wait for persimmon season.
When the leaves of his persimmon tree began to turn color and drop, the anticipation grew. Eventually, the tree was bare of leaves, leaving behind a lovely skeleton of a tree adorned with orange fruit.
That fruit would hang for months, it seemed, and he’d happily harvest them one at a time to eat.
The tree was beautiful in the fall, but the fresh fruit? Blech. If it was underripe, it was terribly astringent. Ripe, it was soft like a pudding, a texture that I just couldn’t handle.
The soft fruit was excellent for baking with, though, and persimmon cookies were annual fall fare.
Know your persimmons
Turns out, I didn’t give fresh persimmons enough of a chance.
Grandpa’s tree was an American persimmon, known for its soft fruit. Years later, someone finally convinced me to give fresh persimmons another chance, promising that a Fuyu persimmon was different.
And they were. Fruit from a fuyu persimmon tree is quite different. Fuyu persimmons are still crunchy when ripe, and they have a flavor that’s a bit spicy and apricot-like. These? I like.
There are a number of persimmon varieties to choose from, each with its own merits and uses.
Which persimmon tree you opt to plant will depend on a number of factors: What grows well in your region, how you plan to use the persimmons, and the space available to you.
Thousands of persimmon cultivars exist, but a few are commonly planted. Of these, there are those that bear astringent fruit and those that bear non-astringent fruits.
The astringent fruits must be very, very soft before they are ripe enough to eat.
Get impatient and you’ll find yourself trying to figure out just what happened. The tannins in an unripe persimmon cause a puckery mouth that is unpleasant.
American persimmon tree – USDA zones 4-10
Not surprisingly, the American persimmon (Diospyros virginiana) is native to North America.
It’s cold-hardier than its Asian counterparts, and larger as well. An American persimmon tree reaches 35′-50 feet in height and width.
Two common named varieties are Prok and Yates. These are self-pollinating, so a single tree will produce fruit.
The fruit of an American persimmon tree is astringent and must be quite soft before it’s considered ripe.
Use the flesh in baking or to pull together a batch of my persimmon granola.
Fuyu persimmon tree – USDA zones 7-10
Bearing non-astringent fruit, this is — bar none — my favorite.
A Fuyu persimmon tree will grow 15′-20′ tall and equally as wide. It’s self-pollinating, so a single tree will produce fruit.
The non-stringent fruit of a Fuyu persimmon tree stays firm when ripe. It’s crunchy like an apple and great for slicing onto a plate for snacking or adding to fresh salads.
Hachiya persimmon tree – USDA zones 7-10
A Hachiya persimmon tree will grow 15′-20′ tall, and like the Fuyu, is self-pollinating.
The acorn-shaped fruit of a Hachiya persimmon tree is another astringent one.
Pull off the calyx and use a spoon to scoop out the pudding-like, almost translucent fruit. Or use it to make a batch of our favorite persimmon cookies.
Persimmon tree care
Plant persimmon trees in full sun. Persimmons prefer well-drained and slightly acidic, fertile soil. Add a layer of mulch around the planting area, but don’t fertilize young trees. Even older trees only require fertilization if growth stalls or leaves lose their dark green color. Use a balanced fertilizer or spread a layer of compost around the base of the tree. Be mindful that too much fertilizer can cause fruit to drop prematurely.
Buying persimmon trees
If persimmons aren’t available at your local nursery, you can order them online during the bare root season. Check these online sellers:
You can read more about growing persimmons here.